I think that blended and online
coursework is wonderful, and I think that even in a digital forum,
student-teacher and student-student interaction is a vital component of
learning, but I don’t see any reason that those types of interactions shouldn’t
be reserved for the learning platforms.
Online class sites can provide discussion boards, message boards, text
chats, voice chats, and many additional forms of media sharing and online
collaboration, and I have yet to hear of any reason that one of those options wouldn’t be equally as effective at disseminating information or facilitating
interactions between students as non-educational social media. Maybe someday someone will change my
mind, but for now, I don’t want to be my students’ friend, Facebook or
otherwise, I want to be their mentor.
Yes, I want my students to approach me with questions, but I don’t want
them to rely on my constant virtual presence. If I do my job, then they can use their knowledge and skills
without me.
Furthermore, when students are
completing my coursework, I want them to be focused on it. I understand that distractions are
inevitable and that most of my students consider themselves to be effective
multitaskers, but I don’t see any reason to exacerbate this behavior by encouraging, or even requiring, students to use social media to stay abreast of
coursework or to complete class activities. I think that combining social media with classwork is
at least as likely to provide a distraction from the classwork as it is to keep
students engaged during out-of-class hours.
Speaking of out-of-class hours, I
feel that the boundary between home and school is beneficial, and should be
respected. Students should not be
constantly on-call. This is
stressful enough for a doctor, so how could it be appropriate for a
teenager? Students have a right to
know when they are off-duty. If
they have participated in class and then completed their homework, then they
should have the opportunity not to think about me or my class for a while. I don’t need to be popping up in their
feed all evening or all weekend.
I expect my students to take the
class as seriously as I do.
Although at times some students do not meet that expectation, I respect the
members of my class enough to assume they are responsible, capable students and
then adapt my strategies for particular individuals that need more
hand-holding. My students are in
high school, so even the youngest are only a few years from voting age and
leaving home, and they have all been doing the education thing for a while
now. Because I take my class seriously, I keep my professional
life and my personal life separate, and I want my students to do the same. Yes, I am all for making a personal
connection and connecting my content material to their personal interests, but
I don’t feel like I have to become an active component of their private lives
in order to do it.
While I really like what you said, I think that there are ways to NOT become an active component of the private lives of students and still use social media as a learning tool. For example, in Twitter you can have students follow you, but you never have to follow the students. This way you wouldn't see what they do outside of what they complete for your class. I think that the convenience that comes with Twitter and Facebook is unmatched right now. You would have to be careful with how you use them though.
ReplyDeleteI also agree that I don't want to be bothered all the time with updates, etc. There needs to be an off time for us as teachers.